Why We Don’t Understand Souls Stories—But Can’t Stop Loving Them
Introduction
The Souls series doesn’t hand you its story—it hides it in shadows, scatters it in cryptic item descriptions, and buries it beneath layers of mystery. You’re never told everything, yet you can’t look away. There’s something intoxicating about piecing together a narrative from fragments, overheard whispers, and forgotten ruins. You may not fully understand the who, the why, or the when—but you feel it. Every crumbling castle, every sorrowful NPC, every haunting boss fight drips with meaning you can’t quite name. That’s the magic: in not knowing, we find ourselves drawn deeper, chasing answers that may never come.

Why We Don’t Understand Souls Stories—But Can’t Stop Loving Them
The Souls series has a strange kind of magic. It doesn’t greet you with a flashy cutscene explaining the world’s history or spoon-feed you the motivations of every character. Instead, it drops you into the ashes of a dying land and simply… lets you wander. You’re not given a neat, linear story—you’re given pieces. Fragments. Hints. A broken sword with a forgotten name. A statue with a face you think you’ve seen before. An NPC whose cryptic words feel like riddles from a dream.
At first, it feels disorienting. You’re used to games that make their stories clear. But here? FromSoftware trusts you to put the puzzle together—or to simply live in the mystery. And that’s part of the pull. You might not understand the lore in the traditional sense, but you feel it. You feel the weight of a world on the brink of collapse. You feel the loneliness of a kingdom long dead. You feel the sorrow in a boss’s desperate final attack.
The vagueness is not a flaw—it’s the point. By withholding, the games create space for your imagination to roam. Players talk, theorize, argue, and explore not because the game tells them to, but because they want to. That shared search for meaning becomes part of the Souls experience itself.
And here’s the secret: you don’t need to know every detail to be moved. You don’t have to understand why the fire is fading to feel the desperation of trying to keep it alive. You don’t have to fully grasp a character’s tragic backstory to be struck by the way they fade into darkness.
The Souls series captures something rare in storytelling—it proves that emotion doesn’t always come from clarity. Sometimes, the most powerful stories are the ones that refuse to explain themselves, the ones that leave just enough unsaid for your mind and heart to fill in the rest.
In the end, maybe we don’t keep coming back to Souls games to understand them. Maybe we come back because they remind us that mystery can be just as beautiful as truth.
More articles from the Understand Souls
More articles from the game Final Fantasy
More articles from the world of Nier
More articles from the game Death Stranding
🎧 Dive Into the Unknown
I’ve recorded a special podcast exploring one of the many deep theories from the world of Nier. While it’s the only episode for now, there’s so much more to discover in the articles below—until the next voice finds its way to you.